By Evan Lindner
April 15th, 2025
Breakdown of What NIL Is
Just 6 years ago, in 2019, college athletes were paid next to nothing during their time in college, but now you are constantly hearing about college athletes signing deals for millions of dollars. Why is that? The simple answer to that is NIL, but what exactly is NIL? NIL is an acronym for Name, Image, and Likeness. Basically, the NIL of an athlete is their personal brand. One common misconception about NIL is that it is a salary from the school; the school in which the athlete competes for has no involvement in NIL payments. The money athletes receive from NIL comes from an outside payer that is not directly associated with the school (Temple News). Before athletes were allowed to profit off of NIL, athletes would have to forego their NCAA eligibility to make money off of their personal brand and therefore not be able to compete in college athletics.
The NCAA allowing athletes to profit off of themselves did not come easily, as it took several cases over the years to get to the point in 2021 where the bill containing NIL finally came to light. Since then, lives have been changed as student-athletes earn life-changing money while in college, which better sets them up for future success, whether they continue their sport or pursue other ventures. This change in the structure of how college athletics operate has caused athletes to leverage social media apps to increase their NIL worth, but also widened the gap between large and small schools in Division 1 athletics.
Below is a timeline of the history of cases and events revolving around NIL.
Importance of Social Media in NIL
With athletes being able to profit off of their personal brand, leveraging social media has become a necessity for many college athletes. With the possibility to earn brand deals with high-profile companies such as Nike, there has been a shift in how social media is used by athletes. Companies have even been created to teach college athletes how to present a clean social media presence that will allow them to maximize their personal brand worth and therefore attract deals. Social media allows athletes to show off their personalities and interests that most people don’t see when they only watch them play their sport.
Three of the most popular ways athletes earn money through NIL are deals with big companies, deals with smaller and more local businesses, and through NIL collectives. NIL collectives will be explained later in this article, but the following paragraphs will dive deep into how both deals with large companies and local businesses are structured.
First, the most popular NIL deals are ones with small businesses that are typically local to the athlete. An example of this is at Division 3, Washington and Lee University athletes signed with a local shop that sold acai bowls. The small store would offer athletes a discount on bowls, and in return, the store and the athletes would post online that they have partnered with each other. These deals could scale to something as small as getting discounts on acai bowls to receiving a brand new car. In 2023, ESPN published an article about how 85 players on the University of Utah football team received leases for brand-new Dodge Ram pickup trucks. The local Dodge dealership sponsored the football team as they felt the benefit of having the local football team at the large university, driving around their trucks would provide positive exposure to Dodge. In return, the athletes received a brand new truck to drive around while in school. These smaller local NIL deals are more popular and feasible for the average college athlete, yet can have a large impact on the life of a student-athlete.
Then there are the NIL deals with large companies. In the summer of 202,4, top basketball prospect Cooper Flagg signed a deal with the nationally recognized brand New Balance. The deal consists of Cooper Flagg wearing and promoting New Balance products, and he will also recieve his own shoe line in the future associated with the New Balance brand (Wojnarowski). The value of this deal is not public information, but according to an ESPN article, it is predicted to be worth millions of dollars, making Cooper Flagg one of the most-paid athletes in the NIL era. These national brands are unfeasible for the majority of college athletes, but for the few that receive them, it provides them with life-changing money that will set them up for future success. These are the deals that make the headlines most often.
Other Impacts of NIL Value
While NIL was created to allow athletes to profit off of their personal brand and image, it has also become where student-athletes are getting paid purely based of off performance. This was not what NIL was created for, but no legislation is stopping this from occurring. Many colleges now have NIL collectives, which are funds run by an organization that collects money from boosters and businesses (Temple News). The funds are then distributed to athletes; oftentimes, the money is distributed as an incentive to play for a certain school rather than playing for others. Quarterback Nico Iamaleava decided to attend the University of Tennessee after receiving a deal worth around $8 million from an NIL collective associated with the school (Sparks).
Deals revolving around NIL collectives often receive more criticism as they go against what NIL was created for. Another impact NIL collectives have had on the realm of college athletics is that it has made the gap between bigger schools and smaller schools larger. Smaller schools at the Division 1 level do not have the support to have large NIL collectives. This has resulted in the bigger schools that are typically in Power 5 conferences attracting all the top talent each year. To add to that, if an athlete has success at a smaller school, it has become the norm to transfer to a larger school as a way to earn more money, meaning smaller schools have trouble retaining talent if they can get them to their school in the first place. To dive deeper into the gaps between schools at the Division 1 level, you can look at the profit, revenue, and expenses produced by each school. Below is an interactive graph and table that shows the financials of Division 1 schools separated by conference.
Graphs made by Evan Lindner but, data from USA Today
Revenue Differences in Big Schools
Surprisingly, a good amount of Division 1 athletic programs operate at a loss, but schools outside of Power 5 conferences tend to operate at a greater loss (Lincoln 2). Power 5 schools consist of schools that are members of the five largest conferences in Division 1 athletics. Those athletics consist of the Big Ten, the Big 12, the SEC, the ACC, and the Pac-12. Non-Power 5 schools consist of any school that is in Division 1 athletics but not in a conference listed above. In total, there are 69 Power 5 schools and 267 non-Power 5 schools. Even though there are over three times more non-Power 5 schools, Power 5 schools bring in over 60% of the revenue (these numbers only include the public universities and not private universities).
One of the main reasons why larger schools are bringing in more revenue is that the conferences they are associated with have larger media deals in place (Lincoln 1). In fact, most of the media deals are related to college football and not any other sport (Lincoln 17). Schools outside of the Power 5 conferences have to resort to other methods to fund their athletics. One popular way is student fees that are directly related to athletics. Each student who attends a university with athletic fees must pay a set amount each semester to fund the sports teams on their campus (Lincoln 19). James Madison University in Virginia is a university with some of the largest athletic fees, with each student at the university paying $2,388 per year to fund their athletic programs, according to the JMU website.
The NCAA is implementing a revenue-sharing model starting in the 2025-2026 year, where around 20% of a school’s athletic department revenues will go back to the student-athletes (Chen). This marks another great milestone in college athletics, where athletes get paid directly by the school, unlike NIL, where money comes from external sources not associated with the school. This will even widen the gap in Division 1 athletics further, as students at bigger schools, where they generate more revenue, will get paid more, making it difficult for smaller schools to compete. Lincoln, in his research paper on college athletics, states that “college athletics is reaching a point where P4 schools are pulling away from G5 schools rapidly and there is no turning back without drastic changes” (Lincoln 32). Now you add paying the athletes in there, and the gap will widen even more. Shifting through the different conferences in the graphs above will demonstrate this further. Below are also visualizations comparing the revenues that schools in Power 5 conferences generate vs schools in non-Power 5 conferences.
Graphs made by Evan Lindner, but data from USA Today
Conclusion
NIL has changed the college athletics landscape forever. Whether it has changed for the better or worse is the better question. There are college athletes getting deals worth millions of dollars daily. On3, a company that tries to predict athletes’ NIL valuations, has Cooper Flagg’s NIL valued at $4.8 million, and LSU gymnast Livvy Dunne valued at $4.1 million. While these are examples of athletes earning a lot of money, the majority of college athletes are not receiving significant or any deals revolving around NIL. This can often create weird team dynamics as one person on the team is earning 5 million dollars and another teammate is earning $0, even though they go through the same practices and put similar efforts into their sport.
The use of social media has drastically increased among athletes over the past few years as it is one of the only ways athletes can increase their brand and NIL valuation. You can go to a popular athlete’s social media, and you are almost guaranteed to find posts that promote a certain product or service that the athlete has an NIL deal with. The lack of regulations related to NIL put forth by the NCAA and Congress has made college athletics the wild west, as there are too many moving parts daily to keep track of. While writing this article, the quarterback of Tennessee, Nico Iamaleava, is receiving a lot of backlash for sitting out of their practices as he wants more money and will not return to the team until a new NIL contract is signed.
Bibliogrpahy
Chen, David W., Jacey Fortin, and Anna Betts. “N.C.A.A. Athletes’ Pay Deal Raises Questions About Future of College Sports.” The New York Times, May 25, 2024, sec. U.S. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/24/us/ncaa-payments-athletes-reaction.html.
Cherullo, Dylan C. “Evaluating the Effect of NIL Laws on College Athletic Department Revenue,” n.d.
Drape, Joe, and Allison McCann. “In College Sports’ Big Money Era, Here’s Where the Dollars Go.” The New York Times, August 31, 2024, sec. Business. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/08/31/business/nil-money-ncaa.html.
“Duke’s Cooper Flagg Signs New Balance Shoe Endorsement Deal – ESPN.” Accessed April 15, 2025. https://www.espn.com/mens-college-basketball/story/_/id/41000405/duke-cooper-flagg-signs-new-balance-shoe-endorsement-deal.
ESPN.com. “‘We’re Giving Everybody Rides’: Utah Football Players Get Free Trucks,” October 5, 2023. https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/38575432/utah-utes-football-receive-trucks-nil-partnership.
Harris, Hailey A., Natasha T. Brison, and Marlene A. Dixon. “Hidden Consequences: Examining the Impact of NIL on Athlete Well-Being.” Journal of Applied Sport Management, 2021. https://doi.org/10.7290/jasm13r7xo.
Lincoln, Joseph. “Financial Transparency in College Athletics: How to Save College Sports from Becoming the Monster It Created and Forge a Path of Sustainability.”
“NCAA and N.I.L Money: How Much Do Athletes Make? – The New York Times.” Accessed February 18, 2025. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/08/31/business/nil-money-ncaa.html?searchResultPosition=5.
“NCAA Finances: Revenue & Expenses by School – USA TODAY.” Accessed April 15, 2025. https://sportsdata.usatoday.com/ncaa/finances.
“Nico Iamaleava, NIL and NCAA’s Investigation into Tennessee Football.” Accessed April 15, 2025. https://www.knoxnews.com/story/sports/college/university-of-tennessee/football/2024/02/05/nico-iamaleava-nil-tennessee-football-ncaa-investigation/72452481007/.
NIL Explained | What Is NIL? What Is Name Image Likeness? | Collectives Explained CleanKonnect, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pm0zi4mvweg.
“On3 NIL Valuations.” Accessed April 15, 2025. https://www.on3.com/nil/rankings/player/nil-valuations/.
Parme, Michael Henry. “Increasing Competition: The Impact of NIL on the NCAA’s Monopsony Power in the Labor Market,” n.d.
Temple Now | news.temple.edu. “Is NIL a Good Thing or a Bad Thing? Sports Industry Expert Weighs In,” June 25, 2024. https://news.temple.edu/news/2024-06-10/nil-good-thing-or-bad-thing-sports-industry-expert-weighs.
“UBO: Tuition and Comprehensive Fee Breakdown.” Accessed April 15, 2025. https://www.jmu.edu/ubo/student-accounts/rates-breakdown.shtml.
Warren, Nicholas Rhea. “THE ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY OF PAYING COLLEGE ATHLETES,” n.d.